Why Hollywood Still Won't Cast Taylor Lautner

Between 2008 and 2012, there was only one pressing entertainment question on the world’s mind: are you Team Edward or Team Jacob? Taylor Lautner, who got his acting start at an early age with roles like Sharkboy, skyrocketed to fame as the werewolf Jacob Black in the "Twilight" franchise. The immense success of the series led many to believe that Lautner would continue to thrive in Hollywood and amass even greater wealth and acclaim.

Unfortunately, things took a different turn. After the "Twilight" saga concluded, Lautner faced a string of unsuccessful films that hindered his career. Critics targeted his performance in "Abduction," describing him as lacking emotional depth and presence. It became clear that Lautner's post-"Twilight" career faced significant challenges, leaving many to wonder why Hollywood has been reluctant to cast him in prominent roles since.

In the years following "Twilight," Lautner did manage to land some roles in projects like the BBC sitcom "Cuckoo" and the Netflix film "Home Team," but his acting career has largely dwindled. So, what are the reasons behind Hollywood's hesitation to cast him again? Let's delve into the factors that contribute to this ongoing narrative.

Taylor Lautner Still Can't Escape Twilight

Jason Merritt/term/Getty Images

The first order of business here is to address the big elephant in the room: "Twilight." While Lautner's co-stars, Kristen Stewart and Robert Pattinson, have managed to distance themselves from the franchise, Lautner has not been so fortunate. A notable incident occurred when Stewart attended Lautner's birthday party in February 2019, sparking a frenzy of "Twilight" reunion excitement online.

It’s clear that Lautner remains closely linked to the franchise, despite its conclusion over a decade ago. This lingering association has led to hesitance from Hollywood executives to cast him in new roles, particularly since Lautner has not made significant efforts to break free from his character Jacob. For now, "Twilight" remains his most recognizable work.

Taylor Lautner Didn't Branch Out While He Had the Chance

Taylor Lautner, Kristin Stewart, and Robert Pattinson

Dave Hogan/Getty Images

When "Twilight" hit theaters in 2008, Taylor Lautner, Kristen Stewart, and Robert Pattinson became some of the hottest young actors in Hollywood. While Stewart and Pattinson pursued diverse roles to avoid being typecast, Lautner largely remained within the confines of his "Twilight" character. His lack of varied projects, aside from minor roles, has contributed to the difficulty in moving beyond the franchise's shadow.

Talks began about Lautner potentially being a one-hit wonder just three years after the last "Twilight" film. A Hollywood agent noted that moving out of the shadow of a hit like "Twilight" is challenging, but with time, Lautner could still redefine his career. However, years later, the struggle to escape this identity remains a significant hurdle for him.

Abduction Did Not Make a Leading Man Out of Taylor Lautner

Lionsgate/YouTube

In 2011, Taylor Lautner attempted to break free from his "Twilight" persona with the romantic action thriller "Abduction." Despite its promising cast and direction, the film failed to connect with audiences and critics alike, grossing only $28 million against a $35 million budget. Critics panned the film, and Lautner's performance was often cited as lacking depth.

While some critics aimed their frustration at the film rather than Lautner, it became evident that the role did not launch him into the leading man status he sought. The film's poor reception ultimately led to a challenging road ahead, as studios grew cautious about casting him in major roles following this disappointment.