Is Anyone From FBoy Island Season 1 Still Together?

Let's face it: there are a ton of dating shows streaming right now! Shows like "The Bachelor," "Love Is Blind," and "Love Island" are just a few of the many that all share a common goal — to find real love. "FBoy Island" entered the scene as a standout contender with a captivating twist — to see if nice guys really do finish last. According to HBO Max, the dating show features three women and potential suitors who move to a tropical paradise where they navigate a dating pool filled with both "nice guys" and "self-proclaimed FBoys," all in search of a lasting love connection.

Hosted by comedian Nikki Glaser, "FBoy Island" aims to inspire women to take control of their dating lives and change the narrative surrounding guys with FBoy tendencies. In a July 2021 interview with ET, Glaser expressed her desire to empower women: "It's about becoming a person that won't let FBoys F with you," she said. Now, after two seasons of the show, fans are left wondering: are any of the Season 1 couples still together? Let's dive into the relationships formed on the show and see who made it and who didn't!

In "FBoy Island," contestants faced the challenge of distinguishing between genuine connections and those fueled by deception. With the stakes high and emotions running deep, the journey of love was anything but straightforward. The show highlighted not only the thrill of romance but also the lessons learned from navigating the complexities of dating in a unique format.

CJ Franco and Jarred Evans

Frazer Harrison/Getty Images

Initially, CJ Franco connected with Casey Johnson, a reformed F-Boy, but she ultimately chose Jarred Evans. This surprising twist showcased her growth as she decided to leave the FBoys behind. CJ was one of the few contestants who picked an actual nice guy. After leaving the Cayman Islands, both CJ and Jarred were optimistic about their long-distance relationship, with Jarred even stating they were "still going strong."

Unfortunately, the couple has since parted ways. In an August 2021 interview with Maxim, CJ reflected on her experience, explaining how she learned to distinguish between good and bad boys. “Nice guys genuinely are interested in you,” she stated, emphasizing how they seek to add value to one’s life without expecting anything in return. CJ also expressed a newfound understanding of dating, saying, “You have to teach people how to treat you,” highlighting the importance of setting boundaries.

Nakia Renee and Jared Motley

Instagram

Nakia Renee, known for her romantic nature, chose Jared Motley, an FBoy, at the end of the show. In a surprising turn, Jared decided to split the $100,000 prize money with Nakia, which initially seemed promising for their relationship. However, they later revealed that they were no longer together, stating they were heading in different directions.

In a candid moment shared via Reddit in September 2021, Nakia expressed, “It was a real relationship,” emphasizing that it wasn’t just for the cameras. While it didn’t work out, she learned an important lesson about taking time to get to know someone when dating. Currently, Nakia is focusing on her music career while still searching for a partner.

Sarah Emig and Garrett Morosky

Instagram

Sarah Emig's journey on "FBoy Island" was tumultuous, especially with her connection to Garrett Morosky, who played the role of the show's villain. Although Sarah initially sought fun and adventure, she found herself in a complicated relationship with Garrett, who was a true FBoy. The finale revealed Sarah's willingness to pursue a relationship outside the show, but Garrett chose not to share the prize money with her.

In an interview with E! News, Sarah reflected on her experience and emphasized the importance of self-love, stating, "I want to serve as a good example... you should always fall in love with yourself first." Despite the challenges, she hopes her story encourages others to trust their instincts and prioritize self-worth in relationships.